Justinian C. Lane, Esq.
Let Justice Be Done, Though the Heavens May Fall

Justinian Lane's Blog

Justinian's Blog

TortDeform.Com Recap

For those of you who haven't checked out TortDeform.com yet, here's a brief recap of some of the articles I've really enjoyed.

Having Their Cake & Eating It, Too:  Cyrus comments upon a great WaPo article that points out how tort reformers want to have their cake - less legal liability - and eat it too - less governmental regulation.  My favorite quote is:

"This isn't an economic argument so much as a political one. A totalitarian state such as China may be able to duck these kinds of trade-offs, and there is no doubt Chinese exporters are more competitive as a result. But that is not realistic for an advanced democracy whose citizens prefer to use some wealth, or forgo some economic efficiency, in exchange for safer products and workplaces and more responsive corporate governance."

Perhaps moving to a slave labor system would make reformers happy.  Certainly, it would increase corporate efficiency.

Lousiana's Supreme Court Gets It Right: Also from Cyrus, this post comments upon the Lousiana Supreme Court's decision to overturn the $500k cap on medical malpractice suits.  Good news like this is rare.

GM Tears Up Our Medical System: I've often argued that before we try and "reform" the medical system, we need to fix it's inefficiencies.  How inefficient is it?

"The automaker loses about $4 million a day because of medical errors and inefficiencies."

That's over $1 billion per year.  Just for GM.  Ouch.

Michigan Gets It W R O N G:  Henry Greenspan covers just how badly broken the liability system is in my current state of Michigan. 

"Michigan suddenly hosted a parade of anti-tort luminaries. Engler teleconferenced his way into an abruptly created "Tort Reform Committee" in the State legislature. Sherman "Tiger" Joyce, President of ATRA, visited Michigan incarnate. So did Daniel Troy, former FDA Chief Counsel and "godfather" of the contemporary FDA preemption doctrine. Troy reworked an earlier paper to include a section specifically defending Michigan's 1995 law, and his talk--presented at a meeting of the Federalist Society in Ann Arbor--was webcast to relevant Michigan legislators and beyond. In the meantime, the 2006 annual meeting of ATRA, opened by special guest Karl Rove, was reportedly much preoccupied by the smoke rising in Michigan. The natives were restless. Clearly, for the pro-immunity boys (they mostly are), it was time to restore order. "

Any cause that both Tiger and Rove support pretty much has to be pure unadulterated evil. 

Justinian's Work: There's the link to see what posts I've made at TortDeform.com.  Most, but not all of my posts there will be cross-posted here.  I just need to figure out the mix.  FYI, I'll be posting at least every Thursday there.  I'm planning on a Thursday post there, and a Friday or Saturday post here.

As always, if you find something you think I'd be interested in, or have any questions, don't hesitate to email me at justinian AT corpreform.com

Tort ReformJustinian Lane